Skip to content

Case study

BRC Mesh Supplier Wins 91% Against Company in Liquidation

A Pahang BRC wire mesh supplier won 91% of an RM800k–900k CIPAA claim against a main contractor in liquidation, including all unpaid work done, interest and costs.

In short. A BRC wire mesh supplier in Pahang claimed RM800k–900k under CIPAA 2012 from a main contractor that had been wound up. With the court's leave, it pursued adjudication while the Official Receiver acted as liquidator. Neither replied. The adjudicator awarded all RM500k–600k of unpaid work done, 1.5% monthly interest to the winding-up date and full costs: 91% of the claim.

At a glance

TradeSupply of BRC wire mesh (construction materials supplier, sub-contractor to the main contractor)
MCS acted forClaimant (supplier)
RespondentMain contractor, wound up by the court in 2023; the Official Receiver acted as liquidator
Contract formPurchase order, delivery order and invoice (30-day terms, 1.5% monthly late interest), plus five further purchase orders
StatePahang
Year of decision2024
Work done (14 invoices)RM600k–700k
Paid before the claimRM100k–200k
ClaimRM800k–900k (RM500k–600k unpaid work done plus RM300k–400k interest)
Outcome100% of unpaid work done; 91% of the total claim including interest
InterestRM200k–300k: simple interest at 1.5% per month from each invoice due date to the winding-up order
CostsRespondent to bear 100% of the adjudication costs (under RM100k), with the consultancy fee reduced

Background

The claimant supplies construction materials. In early 2021 a main contractor building a housing development in Pahang issued it a purchase order to supply BRC wire mesh. The purchase order, the claimant's delivery order and its first invoice formed the contract, worth RM400k–500k. All of them carried 30-day payment terms, and the invoices stated that interest at 1.5% per month would be charged on anything not paid within those terms.

Five further purchase orders followed over the next few weeks for additional supplies. The six purchase orders came to RM800k–900k in total, but some items were later omitted. The claimant delivered in the first quarter of 2021 and issued 14 invoices, worth RM600k–700k. The main contractor signed every delivery order.

Payment was slow. Only RM100k–200k was paid, in instalments between 2021 and early 2023. In late 2022 the main contractor wrote to the claimant confirming that the balance was due, that the agreed 1.5% monthly interest would keep running until it was settled, and that no set-off or back charge would be imposed. The claimant sent a debtor statement in the third quarter of 2023. Nothing more was paid.

The dispute

In the second quarter of 2023 the court wound up the main contractor and appointed the Official Receiver as liquidator.

The claimant did not write the debt off. In the second quarter of 2024 it obtained the court's leave under section 471(2) of the Companies Act 2016 to commence a CIPAA adjudication against the company. The Official Receiver attended that leave hearing.

The claimant then served a payment claim on both the company and the Official Receiver for RM800k–900k. That was RM500k–600k of unpaid work done plus RM300k–400k of late payment interest at 1.5% per month. No payment response was served. The claimant gave notice of adjudication and the AIAC appointed an adjudicator in the third quarter of 2024.

No adjudication response was filed either. Letters to the company's last known address came back undelivered. The Official Receiver received every document but never replied.

Key issues and how they were argued

1. Proceeding against a company in liquidation. The claimant put the winding-up order and the court order granting leave before the adjudicator, and had served its payment claim on the Official Receiver as well as the company. The adjudicator copied all correspondence to the Official Receiver as liquidator. Because nothing came back from either, the adjudicator could rely only on the claimant's documents, and no hearing was needed.

2. Service. The claimant agreed to service by email. The respondent never answered, so the adjudicator directed that documents be served in the ways set out in section 38 of CIPAA, not by email.

3. The deposit. The respondent did not pay its share of the AIAC advance security deposit. The adjudicator directed the claimant to pay it on the respondent's behalf, and it did.

4. How much work was done? The adjudicator found a contract existed: the respondent issued purchase orders, the claimant performed and the respondent acknowledged the work. The adjudicator measured work done by the 14 invoices and the signed delivery orders, not by the value of the purchase orders. Less the RM100k–200k paid, all RM500k–600k claimed was due.

5. Late payment interest. The invoices and purchase orders both set 30-day terms, the invoices set 1.5% per month, and the respondent's late 2022 letter agreed the rate. The adjudicator accepted both. The claim did not say whether its figure was simple or compound interest, so the adjudicator recalculated it as simple interest. Interest at 1.5% per month was allowed only up to the date of the winding-up order. Together, these reduced it to RM200k–300k.

6. Costs. Under section 18 of CIPAA costs follow the event, so the respondent was ordered to bear all costs. The consultancy fee claimed, RM100k–200k, was reduced to under RM100k as excessive for a documents-only monetary claim with no response from the other side.

The decision

  • 100% of the unpaid work done (RM500k–600k) awarded
  • Late payment interest of RM200k–300k at 1.5% per month, simple, from each invoice due date to the winding-up order
  • In total, RM700k–800k, or 91% of the RM800k–900k claim
  • Respondent to bear 100% of the adjudication costs, including AIAC fees, the adjudicator's fees and a reduced consultancy fee (under RM100k)
  • Payment by the end of 2024

The decision does not deal with how the award will be paid out of the liquidation. That is a separate step after the decision.

Every case turns on its own facts and documents; past outcomes do not guarantee a similar result. This is not legal advice.

Lessons for contractors

  1. 1Liquidation does not have to end your claim. Here the claimant obtained the court's leave under the Companies Act 2016, then ran a normal CIPAA adjudication against the wound-up company.
  2. 2Serve the liquidator too. The payment claim went to the Official Receiver as well as the company, and the adjudicator copied all correspondence to it.
  3. 3Invoices and signed delivery orders prove work done. The award was based on them, not on the larger purchase order total.
  4. 4Put the interest rate in writing. A 1.5% monthly rate on the invoices, confirmed in the respondent's own letter, produced RM200k–300k in interest. In this decision, interest stopped at the winding-up order.
  5. 5Budget for the other side's deposit. A respondent that does not engage may leave you to pay its share of the adjudication deposit.

The award for the unpaid supplies was won through a CIPAA payment claim. Turning a decision into payment is covered under enforcing an adjudication decision. For another unpaid-invoice claim built on purchase orders and a late interest term, see the lift subcontractor case.

This case study is anonymised. Names, project details and exact figures have been removed or rounded. Shared with the client's consent.

FAQs

Can you bring a CIPAA claim against a company in liquidation?
In this case, yes. The respondent had been wound up, so the claimant first obtained the court's leave under section 471(2) of the Companies Act 2016 to commence the adjudication. The payment claim was also served on the Official Receiver as liquidator, which received all of the adjudicator's correspondence, and the adjudicator decided the claim on the claimant's documents.
What happens if a respondent in liquidation never responds?
Here, no payment response or adjudication response was served and the Official Receiver never replied. The adjudication went ahead on the documents. The claimant paid the respondent's share of the AIAC deposit when directed, and the decision was issued within the 45 working days under section 12(2)(b) of CIPAA.
Is late payment interest awarded against a company in liquidation?
In this decision, yes, up to the winding-up order. The invoices set 30-day terms with 1.5% monthly interest, and the respondent had agreed that rate in writing. The adjudicator allowed simple interest from each invoice due date to the date of the winding-up order.

Anonymised and shared with client consent.

TelephoneWhatsApp